Showing posts with label Gluk-Gluk Sound. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gluk-Gluk Sound. Show all posts

Saturday, February 22, 2014

LCA Bushings vs Stabilizer Bushings

Its been about 10 months since I got my current ride. When it arrived, it has cracked lower control arm bushes and worn stabilizer bushes. The bad LCA bush can be seen visually but the bad stabilizer bushings can't.

I concluded this from the worn right hand tyres when I first inspected the tyres. My previous ride also had the same issue. You can read my "gluk" battle post for that story.

So when I got this X, the first thing I did was to immediately replace the stabilizer bushings.

After 15,000km and 3 wheel services later, I do not see any uneven wear on the tyres.

Is it safe to conclude that it is possible that you ignore the LCA bushings until a much later time?
If you are cash strapped, maybe. But if money and time are not an issue, please get those bushes changed out.

Change the bush at a workshop outside. If you do it back at Nissan, the will make you change the whole lower control arm. Thats going to cost a bomb ^_^


Monday, August 24, 2009

Gluk - Final Episode

After whole day at TCEAS, I believe I can finally close the chapter on Gluk. Yay!!

Who was the culprit? The stabilizer bar bushings. Off all things. Who would have thought 2 pieces of rubber could have caused so much headaches.


So how much did this part cost ? RM30 a piece. TCEAS apparently have RM30 listed as the price as well. Unfortunately they did not have stock so I had to go visit my friendly neighbourhood spare part shop Double Champion.


Installation took a little more than 30 minutes as they had to dislodge the tie rod ends to access the stabilizer bushing nuts.

I will be writing another piece later on as a post mortem for gluk. Stay tuned!

___________________

Well the stabilizer bushings did not take a whole day, today I made an appointment with TCEAS's chief technical to troubleshot pop noise while going through bumps and the gluk noise.

There were a few test drives involved, removing the left strut and installing it back. We found the right inner tie rod faulty and that had to be replaced. TCEAS pricing puts it at RM225 after a 10% discount and another RM45 for labour. I still think TCEAS parts pricing is cut throat. They comfort you with a 90 days warranty.. bah...

Anyway the strut was removed and disassembled to look for problems. None could be seen visually. The test drive after it was refitted.... no more noise. At least for the time being. Going to monitor this.

I'm guessing its due to this little part. See picture below. Assembly could have been shot previously.

One interesting bit observed during testing was the difference between damping for Tan Chong OEM absorbers and Tokico Japan absorbers. It took a lot of effort to press down the shaft for the Tokico Japan ones. The Tan Chong OEM just goes up and down easily.
  • T30 Absorber: Tokico Japan - Hard
  • T30 Absorber: ETCM OEM - Soft





Sunday, May 17, 2009

Inner Tie Rod Socket Replaced


I had the replacement job done at Kedai Tayar and Bateri Relau. It was simple enough.
  1. Removed the wheel
  2. Dislodge the tie-rod ends
  3. Remove clips securing the boot cover(aka bellows)
  4. Remove the boot cover
  5. Used this clau like device to unscrew the tie-rod
  6. Insert replacement and screw back
  7. Realign wheels...
Unfortunately.. it was still going pop pop pop pop pop pop pop pop pop after that... :( bummer
Thinking back, the sound only started happening after the shocks were replaced. Could there have been some issues with the installation? hmmm......

Looks like I'm going to be trying to figure out this sound next... pop!!


The new inner tie rod ends (RM250)


The old one - Looks like there are rust deposits on it.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

Gluk: LCA Bush Revisited

I almost thought the issue with the gluk was over until they jacked up my car during an oil change last weekend. To my surprise, I found the large lower arm bush cracked even worse than before. Got me thinking, what the heck was wrong. 

Check out those cracks... its worse when its on the car.

Something doesn't feel right and I started to suspect something was a miss with the previous LCA bush replacement earlier. Acting on a hunch i decided to replace both the arms. Bought the replacements for left and right @RM600 each. Now that really cost an arm (no pun intended hehe)

Notice anything yet?


Looking at the new arms.. I immediately suspected something when I first saw the orientation of the connecting piece to the body. The bushes has orientation marks on them!! Now I just need to confirm the suspision when I have the LCA arms on the X removed.

True enough to my suspicion. The previous LCA bush installation did not follow the orientation markers. Arrgh!! Damn the Chang Soon foreman and their pressing workshop !! So a word of advice to all that plans to replace their LCA bushes to save money. Please check the bush press to make sure the orientation markers are correct. Else you'd be screwed to replace them again.


The replacement job was done at Kedai Tayar and Bateri Relau (Bridgestone). Charged me RM20 for replacing the arms.

Total damage RM1200 + RM40 for labour + RM24 to realign the wheels.

Driving around, the steering definitely feels more "stiff" and the road harshness don't feel that hard anymore.



---------------------------------------------------------
If you find this information helpful please support me via any of the ads on this page. Thank you.
---------------------------------------------------------

Saturday, April 11, 2009

Replacement: Rod-Stabilizer / Rod A-Connecting

The latest attempt to resolve the Gluk. Today's hangout place after lunch is a big Bridgestone tyre shop in Relau. Can't miss it.

This is the original left absorber link after being removed

Drove into the shop and gave them an overview on the gluk. The foreman took the car for a test drive then came back and had his helpers removed the left front wheel. After that he had what he termed the absorber link removed. Reattached the wheel and tested the car again. Claims the sound was no more. I took a go at it and yes its true enough the gluk disappeared without the absorber link.

The new replacement unit


Same part but different part number and description
Rod-Stabilizer or Rod A-Connecting ? Should I be worried?

Left Side


Right Side



Replacement cost me RM135 x 2 = RM270 in total.

Drove away skeptical whether was it really fixed. I still think its there but then again, today I have a blocked nose and slight fever so I could be hearing things. The usual 1 week adjustment period test will be applied.

Praying hard this will solve the problem...

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Gluk currently leads by 3-0

It is sad to say, all the repairs to date has yet to resolve this problem. I could feel that it much less obvious now thanks to the  new engine mounts but the gluk gluk gluk sound is still there.

The latest thing i notice is that the alignment is slightly off. :-?
Just had the alignment done right before getting the engine mounts changed. A surprising turn of events was I got a call from TC. They called to check if the car was ok.. I told them the problem was still there and they offered to have me bring the car in for further diagnosis. 

??!!??!?? 

Why so helpful all of a sudden? They almost refuse to entertain me earlier, I had to ask the right questions and be in the workshop to check on the things myself when the car was sent in for other jobs.... hmmmm.....

Anyway back to the problem at hand. Here are some new observations. As bumps are a plenty in the office, i realised these :-

  1. Taking bumps head on fast or slow does not yield that gluk sound
  2. Taking on bumps slowly while turning will yield the sound. (This is when one tyre moves up first then followed by the tyre from the other side.
I think I'm closer to solving this. Just hope the parts that I replaced recently don't get damage again with problem at hand.



Sunday, March 15, 2009

The Gluk-Gluk Strikes Back !!

Damn ! The Gluk-Gluk is still there. What on earth is causing it??!!?!??!!! Arrrgh!!!

I was at Queensbay Mall for lunch. Parked the car at the open air carpark. The place was filled with pot holes and bumps. Totally uneven terrain. Was driving  S L O W L Y to navigate the best path out and then it happened. Gluk... Gluk.... Gluk.... when i passed moved over bumps and potholes that made the car ride up one side after another... 

My observation so far :-
  1. No more gluk gluk sound when driving on tar road or in the apartment compound (maybe its unnoticable?)
  2. Gluk sound damn obvious when driving in VERY uneven terrain
  3. The vehicle feels more responsive. Less idle time between throttling and the car doing something (maybe its just my butt?)
  4. Fuel gauge seems to be moving slower than before (but that could be the weather and the highway travels...hmm..)
What else could be broken?
  1. Links?
  2. Stabilizer bar?
  3. Connecting Rods?
  4. Ball Joint?
I am lost at this point. Need to go back and do more research and a better mechanic to help me diagnose this. 

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Out comes the old engine mountings

Finally got the my X-trail back at 2pm. The car spent 1.5 days at Tan Chong. It was ready in the car park but no one called me >_< . Luckily I decided to stop over after lunch. Caught them unprepared. Documents were not ready. 

They included 2 "missing" clips for my air filter intake which so happen to be secured properly by cable tie when I sent the car in. They wanted to charge me RM4.50 for each of those clip when I already had a bag of those under the arm rest. I had them take it out and replaced it with my own on the spot. =P
Anyway back to the mountings and all the gluk gluk sound...

Here are the old ones. There are some serious cracks in each one of them. Luckily I purchased and had all four of the mountings replaced. I've marked the fault areas on the mounts. Please click on the  image for a better view of the mounting faults.

Rear mounting - Visible cracks.


Front mounting - Slight crack and material fatigue.


Left hand mounting - Visible cracks. 


Right hand mounting - Small cracks are starting to appear.

I am seriously wondering where on earth did the previous owner drag the X-trail through. This is a 2003 model. Its only been like 5 years. Maybe it was 5 years of neglect?

Anyway back to the topic of gluk.. Will this solve that annoying gluk-gluk sound thats been bothering me? I still can't tell through the preliminary tests. I'll probably conclude it after a week or so after the brain overcomes the euphoric phase of replacing a new part in the X-trail.

Fingers crossed everyone !!

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

New: Engine Mounting



I bought new engine mounts for my X-trail few days ago. Cost me RM725 for all four. Going to take the car back to TCEAS for installation. Over the phone they said it will cost me RM152 and it will take 2 days !!??!?! The Chief Mech Zam said the X-trail requires careful calibration and measurement after installation.. betul ke ni? 

Making the appointment tomorrow hehe.

Gluk sound - Your days are numbered !!

Saturday, February 28, 2009

That annoying "gluk" - Part III : Post Strut Replacement

Its been a week since the front struts have been chanced. The "gluk" sound was sort of muffled during the first 2 days of driving. In order to make sure the springs and struts seat properly, I purposely drove over some bumpy roads to shake them in place =P

Now.. the "gluk" is still there. But it now sound more accurate. From inside the car it seems like its coming from the center and you can sort of feel it through the vibrations.

Could this be the failed engine mount??!?

Has the strut replacement helped pinpoint the source ?? 

So next on the list of suspects are the Engine Mounts. These are costly. I need to do more shopping first. So far I've been quoted RM590 to RM800+ for the X-Trail's mounts. And most of them don't keep stock. Bah!



 

That annoying "gluk" - Part II: Front Struts

Thought the mystery was over with the LCA bushing replaced but after a few days my friendly neighbourhood "gluk" is back !! Arrgh!!

What to replace next? So I went down my suspect lists again and shortlisted a few more.
  • Struts
  • Strut mounts
  • Spring Rubber Seat
Again time was spent shopping around looking for parts and cost. Still Double Champion is still the champion for low cost parts. I'll talk more about spare parts shop in another post.

Spent RM400 for the following parts.
  1. 2 units of X-trail (T30) Front Struts - Original Tokico from Japan @RM185 ea
  2. 2 pcs of Strut dust cover @RM18 ea
The box. I'm still wondering if this is really from Japan.
The Importer. Unfortunately they only do wholesale don't entertain retail buyers. I called.

The dust cover. Works for Cefiro to. Wonder what else X-trail(T30) and Cefiro(A32) share? hmm...

For installation. The "entau" at the shop recommended me to a workshop behind KFC Sungai Dua with blue roof next to a temple. His buddy charged me RM 40 to installed both.


That annoying "gluk" - Part I: LCA bushing

It sucks when there are weird sounds coming from somewhere in the car. Its been 3 months since I took over ownership of this Nissan X-trail.  Currently I'm being plague by this "gluk-gluk-gluk" sound that keeps bugging me whenever i drive real slow. Observation over the weeks were summarized as below :-
  • Happens when driving under 20kmh over uneven surface
  • More obvious when only one side of the tyre hits bumpy roads
  • Dampens and unaudible when 2 person sits in the car
Got sick of the sound went to TCEAS and had them jack up the car to check. The chief found both the lower control arm bushings cracked and the underside rear mount was also starting to go. WTF is a LCA ?

Left Side

Right Side

See the cracks on the rubber?

TCEAS and general spare parts shop don't stock the bushings. They sell the whole LCA assy which cost around RM700 ea excluding labour.

My search for parts ended at Double Champion (Sg Dua). Got my bushings and went to get them installed at Chang Soon in Sungai Ara. I would recommend them for alignment job but the installation job was pretty expensive @ RM45 per side. They also chopped me when they sent the LCA out to press @RM30/RM25 big/small when it cost about RM15. >_<


Both are labelled Made in Japan but the shop says they are local. Your guess is as good as mine.
  • X-Trail Lower Control Arm Big Bushing - 2pcs @RM38 
  • X-Trail Lower Control Arm Small Bushing -2pcs @RM28

By the time this ended, was almost 9pm. Everything was set. Drove around, didn't hear anything yet but will have to run this abit before the assy sit properly. Hopefully no more "gluk" "gluk"

Today's damage was about RM400+ vs RM1400 if I had replaced the LCA assy.